SmartyTalent Blog: AI in recruiting. A person decides.

The candidate is waiting for an answer. What silence in recruiting costs and how to shorten it

Written by Slawomir Kroczak | Nov 5, 2026, 8:00:00 AM

A candidate sends an application and waits. A week, two, sometimes for good. For you it is one of many openings. For them it is a question nobody answered.

What silence looks like from the other side

No reply is not an exception. In the eRecruiter survey “Candidate Experience w Polsce 2025” (Candidate Experience in Poland 2025), more than nine in ten candidates had been left without information that they were rejected, and 84% of respondents say it happens repeatedly.

The candidate does not see your calendar or the number of applications. They see only that they spent time on a form and documents, and then nothing happened. They do not know whether the application arrived. They do not know whether anyone read it. They do not know whether to keep waiting or to look elsewhere.

Nothing can be read from silence, so the candidate fills in the rest themselves. They have no reason to assume anything good about a company that did not write back.

What silence costs

The cost of silence is in no budget, which makes it easy to miss. According to the eRecruiter survey “Candidate Experience w Polsce 2025”, 71% of candidates judge a company by its recruitment. For someone from outside, the hiring process may be their only direct contact with your company. How you treat them becomes their picture of the whole organisation.

The cost has several parts:

  • The employer brand. The careers page and campaigns say one thing, and no reply says another. The candidate will remember what they experienced themselves.
  • Future openings. A person who does not fit the position today may be a good candidate for another in a year. After silence they may no longer want to apply to you.
  • The team's time. A candidate without an answer may write or call to ask what happens next. Someone answers those questions anyway, only later and one by one.
  • The candidates you care about. A person who does not know where they stand keeps looking and may accept another offer.

Why teams stay silent

Employers state the reasons plainly. In the eRecruiter survey “Candidate Experience w Polsce 2025”, 59% of employers point to a lack of time and too many candidates.

It is an honest answer. In a large recruitment process, feedback loses out to work that has a deadline: interviews, arrangements with the manager, the next job ad. A rejection is also the hardest message to write. You have to give a reason, find the tone and write nothing the company will regret later. So it is put off until later, and “later” easily turns into “never”.

The conclusion is practical. If the cause is a lack of time, an appeal for better communication alone will change nothing. What has to change is who prepares the messages and when.

How to shorten the silence before the job opens

A large part of this work can be done earlier, before the first application arrives. It does not take a new tool.

  • Measure the silence. Take the last closed recruitment process and check how many candidates received any answer and after how many days. Without that knowledge, a conversation about contact with candidates stays a conversation about impressions.
  • Confirm the application. It is the simplest message in the whole process and you only need to prepare it once. The candidate knows at once that the application arrived.
  • Base the reasons for rejection on the requirements of the position. If the requirements are written down before the job opens, the reason for a rejection already exists: it is the requirement the candidate does not meet. Such a message speaks about the position, not about the person.
  • Agree the tone. Once, for the whole company or for a given opening: formal or relaxed, and how detailed the explanations should be. Then nobody starts a rejection from a blank page.
  • Name the person who approves. A rejection is a decision about a person. Someone on the team should read and approve it before the message goes out. They should also know that it is their task.

A good rejection is short. It thanks the candidate for applying, says plainly that they are not going forward and gives a reason tied to the requirements of the position. It does not judge the person and does not leave them guessing.

An example: AI prepares, a person approves

This is how we arranged the work in the SmartyTalent virtual recruiter. It is an AI that runs the first stage of recruitment and does this work for the team.

The candidate fills in a short form, adds a CV and receives a confirmation that the application has arrived. Their CV is read against the same criteria as the CVs of the other candidates. The criteria are set by the manager of the team that is hiring.

A candidate whose application matches the requirements receives a text message with three times for a short phone call and picks the one that suits them. If they do not answer the phone, they receive a text message with new times to choose from. Before the call they hear that it is recorded and that a virtual AI assistant is conducting it. They can ask for a person: when they say so on the call or do not agree to the recording, someone from the employer's team calls them back. A candidate who goes forward receives an invitation to the next stage.

Nobody writes a rejection from a blank page either. When a candidate does not go forward after the rating of the application or after the phone call, the virtual recruiter proposes a rejection and gives the reasons. The message lists the requirements of the position that the candidate does not meet. The employer sets the tone and the level of detail. A rejection after a rating is approved by a person before the message reaches the candidate. The message goes out during working hours or waits as a draft for approval.

It also has to be said plainly what happens without a person. An answer to a question about a must-have requirement, for example a driving licence, can close an application automatically. The candidate can ask a person to check that decision.

To check at your company

  • Does a candidate at your company receive a confirmation that the application arrived?
  • How many candidates from the last recruitment process received an answer, and after how many days?
  • Do the reasons for rejection follow from the requirements of the position written down before the job opened?
  • Who agreed the tone of messages to candidates, and where is it written down?
  • If a tool or a vendor prepares the messages, who approves a rejection before it reaches the candidate?

Film (in Polish): “No more silence: the candidate knows where they stand”

Silence in recruiting gets shorter when the work is divided well: messages can be prepared in advance, and writing them can be handed to a tool. A person decides who receives a rejection and what they read in it.

Book a 30-minute demo